The ethics in the search for a cure

As you can read in my previous post, type 1 Diabetes Mellitus (T1DM) is caused by the deficiency of the insulin producing Beta-cells in the pancreas. It’s the body’s own white blood cells that attack these Beta-cells.

One of the most promising and upcoming treatments involves the use of stem cells. They could be grown in a certain way so they would differentiate into insulin-producing cells. Stem cells can be derived from a couple of sources like the umbilical cord, bone marrow and embryonic cells as you can see in the figure below. Of course deriving stem cells from embryonic cells raises ethical questions like no other. Can we justify the extraction of stem cells, and therefor the death of a human embryo in order to potentially cure a T1DM patient?

Image

(Aguayo-Mazzucato, C., & Bonner-Weir, S. (2010). Stem cell therapy for type 1 diabetes mellitus. Nature Reviews Endocrinology, 6(3), 139–148. Retrieved from http://www.nature.com/nrendo/journal/v6/n3/fig_tab/nrendo.2009.274_F1.html)

Using these pluripotent cells doesn’t come without any challenges. Culturing embryonic cells is difficult without them already differentiating. This results in potential tumor growth as well. The biggest issue however is the possibility of immune rejection after transplantation. So immune-surppresant medication would be necessary.

Another source of stem cells may be of somatic nature instead of embryonic, stem cells from bone marrow tissue for example. The major advantage is that stem cells of non-pancreatic origin can differentiate into insulin-producing Beta-cells. This is astonishing as it was always believed that stem cells from somatic origin can only differentiate into specialised cells from the tissue of which they were extracted. This research hasn’t reached clinical trials yet but when these stem cells of bone marrow tissue were transplanted into mice, they differentiated into functional insulin-producing cells.

Using these somatic stem cells is a much more ethical way of finding the cure in the research of T1DM. Using stem cell research can indeed be ethically viable in the pursuit of a treatment for diabetes. As somatic stem cells don’t generally induce an immune reaction, this gives them an advantageous edge over embryonic stem cells.

In my own opinion, there is more research needed to determine the exact advantage of somatic stem cells versus embryonic stem cells. More tests need to be performed to conclude that the immune system doesn’t get triggered after transplantation. The advancements in medicine can never increase without the rise of ethical questions. For instance the use of lab animals is an ethical stumbling block yet a necessary one for human lives to be saved.

Stem Cells in the Treatment of Diabetes: Therapeutic Potential and Ethical Considerations

 

Advertisements

3 responses to “The ethics in the search for a cure

  1. Pingback: Saved by the lab mice | Proteomics and the pathogenic mechanism of diabetes·

  2. I do not know if you heard of it already, but a few days back on the news I heard that scientists have discovered a way to use the cells from mice to turn into stem cells when put into an acid bath. I find this amazing and better than the use of embryonic cells. What is your opinion on this and do you think most of these ethnical questions are now no problem anymore?

  3. That is amazing, I had not heard of this before. That is the whole purpose isn’t it, to harvest stem cells from places that don’t go against ethically inappropriate situations like it is with embryonic stem cells. Like you can read in my blog post, these somatic stem cells and what you mention in your comment are recently discovered. This must be tested as soon as possible to start using these non-ethical stem cells. That way I think the problem will indeed go away… until they find something else to be ethically concerned about of course.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s